Friday, 24 March 2017

Book Review - The Butterfly Garden - Dot Hutchinson

I saw this book on Goodreads as one of the best thrillers of 2016 - I looked into the blurb of the book and just knew I had to read it. And read it I did, all in one night.

If you don't like rape, kidnapping, child molestation, abuse and more (like is probably the wrong word but you know what I mean) then this book definitely isn't for you. Its dark, gritty and utterly captivating.

The chapters are split into police interviews, where we get to meet FBI agents  Victor Hanoverian and Brandon Eddison  and first person recountings of the Butterfly Garden, told by victim Maya. I liked the layout of this retelling, we got to see right into the story of the butterfly garden, but also get to ask ourselves how trustworthy this first person recounting is - Maya was getting interviewed by the FBI after-all, can we believe everything she has to say?

I did find it difficult to actually imagine the Butterfly Garden though. I couldn't really grasp the sheer size of it, and how the girls within could have gone unnoticed for so long, however, after a while I just went with it and got completely absorbed with the story.

There have been complaints that the writing of the women is sexist, and they all just go along with what their captor tells them. And in some ways I understand this, Maya especially seems to just keep quiet and do as she is told, however, as explained in the book, if you push too far you die and get put on display for all the other girls to see. I don't think we can really judge as we have never been in that situation! Though I would like to think I would fight, then how would I get out of the garden? Would I actually be brave enough to fight when so many before me haven't been able to get free?

I just really enjoyed this book, it was something different from what I usually read, it had all the darkness and brutality that I wanted, that I expect of a book that claims to be potentially offensive. It was just really great 5/5



  1. Oh my gosh, I absolutely loved this book! So dark, mysterious and intriguing! I couldn't put it down.
    It was really different from the kinds of things I normally read and I loved it :)

    1. I'm so glad you loved it too! I didn't know what to think going in but it was awesome!


© Sammi KM | All rights reserved.
Blog Layout Created by pipdig